Discovering David Sedaris
And why I hope we never meet
I discovered David Sedaris in what I’ll call a “video classroom setting” (because no one is paying me to say otherwise). It wasn’t a live reading, nor was it through one of his famous essay collections. Instead, it was him sitting on a stool, talking about writing with the same dry, unflinching delivery that makes his stories so damn funny. And it wasn’t just the content — his life observations, his peculiar little fascinations, his complete indifference to whether anyone else agreed with him — it was how he told them. His humor was so dry it barely registered as humor at all, just an extension of how he naturally spoke. It got me thinking about how we tell stories — not just on the page but out loud, in a room full of people, in a way that makes them lean in instead of glaze over.
So I bought Holidays on Ice. I laughed out loud — actually, out loud, which is rare. His piece about being a Macy’s elf, the indignities of forced cheer, the absurdity of adults who take Santa photos far too seriously — perfection. But something else about him struck me: his aversion to dogs. This man, this brilliant, biting, openly gay writer, does not like dogs. And here I am, a straight, white woman with six dogs, utterly charmed by him. What kind of cosmic joke is that? How are we even kindred spirits? Yet, here I am, seeking out his outlook on the world like a lifeline, despite our polar opposite takes on canine companionship.
Performing Writing vs. Just Writing
I’ve always read my work out loud as part of the editing process. But since discovering Sedaris, it’s changed. Now, I don’t just read — I perform. I imagine myself on stage, a single spotlight hitting me, dressed to the nines, martini glasses clinking in the audience, my bunion throbbing in a pair of ridiculous heels. The rhythm, the cadence, the delivery — it all matters in a way I hadn’t considered before. Writing isn’t just about words on a page; it’s about how those words sound, how they land, how they make someone feel. And Sedaris? He’s a master of that.
Being an Outsider (Turns Out, It’s a Universal Thing)
Feeling like an outsider is as natural to me as breathing. I grew up in a world that rejected me, often for reasons that even the rejecters couldn’t articulate. Turns out, there’s a name for that: autism. But it took me over 50 years to realize it. Society shuns autistic people in ways that are often invisible, subtle, and deeply ingrained. We don’t “fit,” and so we’re quietly left out.
Sedaris, in his own way, gets that. He grew up in an era when being gay wasn’t the social currency it can be today — it was something that made you other. Add to that his size, which he jokes about in Holidays on Ice, and you have a man who knows what it’s like to live on the outside of things, looking in. And yet, he doesn’t beg to be included. He stands there, notebook in hand, observing, making notes, and then later, turning it all into something razor-sharp and hilarious.
Why I’ll Never Meet Him
There’s an old saying: Never meet your heroes. I’ve tested this theory before, and let me tell you — it holds up.
Once, I admired a writer from afar. Her byline always caught my eye. She was a product of the same community I grew up with and she managed to become a celebrity of sorts, in certain circles. She wrote about things I loved, and I thought, “Yes, this. This is who I want to be.” Then I met her. And she was awful. Not just a little off-putting — flat-out unpleasant. A female misogynist who sneered at other women, who name-dropped while accusing others of name-dropping, who casually referred to the women carrying flags at a very prominent rodeo as “flag hags,” and that’s the moment I realized: Some people are better from a distance. And that’s not a reflection of Sedaris, it’s a reflection of fear. I’m sure he’s just as delightful as he appears through his writing, but I’ll take “things that were never going to happen anyway” for $500 Alex.
So, while I adore David Sedaris, I have no plans to meet him. What if he’s mean to me? What if he thinks I’m annoying? What if he — God forbid — uses my foibles in an essay? I’d rather keep my image of him intact: a brilliant, oddball observer of humanity, eternally scribbling in his notebook, telling stories that feel both wildly personal and universally relatable.
And maybe, just maybe, he’ll never have to know that one of his biggest fans has a house full of dogs.